Best Cheap Car Insurance Companies
Shelbyville IN

Secure connection. No spam. No hidden fees.


Cheap Auto Insurance Rates Near Me


Cheap Auto Insurance in Shelbyville Indiana

Car Insurance Quotes by Age of Driver in Shelbyville, IN

Age of Driver Insurance Cost
Teens $3,754
20 Years $1,487
30 Years $1,145
40 Years $1,102
50 Years $1,020
60 Years $1,034
70 Years $1,204

Best Auto Insurance Companies in Indiana

Auto Owners

Indiana Farmers

Geico

Erie

Progressive

NAIC Market Share

1.28%

4.16%

13.45%

1.34%

12.25%

S&P Global Ratings

AA+

A

AA+

AA

A

Average Full Coverage Yearly Premium

$1,025

$918

$669

$663

$1,100

Discount Rating

5 stars

4 stars

5 stars

4 stars

5 stars


Auto Owners

Indiana Farmers

Geico

Erie

Progressive

NAIC Market Share

1.28%

4.16%

13.45%

1.34%

12.25%

S&P Global Ratings

AA+

A

AA+

AA

A

Average Full Coverage Yearly Premium

$1,025

$918

$669

$663

$1,100

Discount Rating

5 stars

4 stars

5 stars

4 stars

5 stars


Auto Owners

Indiana Farmers

Geico

Erie

Progressive

NAIC Market Share

1.28%

4.16%

13.45%

1.34%

12.25%

S&P Global Ratings

AA+

A

AA+

AA

A

Average Full Coverage Yearly Premium

$1,025

$918

$669

$663

$1,100

Discount Rating

5 stars

4 stars

5 stars

4 stars

5 stars

Car Insurance Companies Near Me

Olinger Insurance

420 S Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176

(317) 398-8936

No website found

Shelter Insurance - Brady Ramsey

637 S Harrison St, Shelbyville, IN 46176

(317) 398-2886

https://www.shelterinsurance.com/CA/agent/BRADYRAMSEY

Scott Richards: Allstate Insurance

104 S Vine St, Shelbyville, IN 46176

(317) 392-2101

https://agents.allstate.com/scott-richards-shelbyville-in.html

Kyle Henderson: Allstate Insurance

37 Public Square, Shelbyville, IN 46176

(317) 392-2123

https://agents.allstate.com/kyle-henderson-shelbyville-in.html

Kenneth Kreish American Family Insurance

266 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176

(317) 392-4678

https://agent.amfam.com/Kenneth-Kreish/

Brooks Insurance Professionals, Inc.

223 S Harrison St ste c, Shelbyville, IN 46176

(317) 392-9454

http://www.premier-realty-group.net/

Average Annual Vehicle Insurance by Credit Score

Credit Rating Average Rate
Average of All Credit Ratings $1165
Below Fair $1725
Poor $1875
Worst $2040

car insurance companies Shelbyville IN

How to Save on Car Insurance in Shelbyville

Do your research
Compare quotes from different places
Take advantage of policy bundles
Look at vehicle safety ratings
Participate in discount programs through driver training or safe driving rewards
Maintain a good credit rating
car insurance companies Shelbyville IN

Shopping for Car Insurance in Shelbyville, IN

It's never been easier to shop around for affordable car insurance. You can use online tools to instantly get quotes from car insurance companies in Shelbyville, Indiana.


Make sure to get the right amount of coverage you need. Do you only need Liability insurace, which provides minimum coverage? Some people require Full Coverage, especially when the car is financed.


Once you've done the research, comparison shopped the rates you found, and figured out your discounts, you're now ready to buy the best and cheapest car insurance in Shelbyville, IN.